Criminal lawyer in Reno & Northern Nevada

Why Wasn’t I Read My Miranda Rights When I Was Arrested?

Why Wasn’t I Read My Miranda Rights When I Was Arrested?

Police car arrives to read miranda rights

A Case Does Not Get Dismissed Just Because the Police Didn’t Read You Miranda Rights

The Miranda Rights are a result of a 1966 U.S. Supreme Court case, Miranda v. Arizona.

  • You have the right to remain silent
  • Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law
  • You have the right to an attorney
  • If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be provided for you
  • Do you understand the rights I have just read to you?
  • With these rights in mind, do you wish to speak to me?

Television and movie police dramas often read Miranda Rights to suspects to make arrests look exciting. As a result of this mainstream media use, many Americans think they have a strong understanding of Miranda Rights. Many people believe that Miranda Rights must be read during every police interaction or arrest. They couldn’t be more wrong.

Police Only Read Miranda Rights During Custodial Interrogations

The police are only required to read a suspect their Miranda Rights if they are conducting an interrogation.  An interrogation can be a line of questioning, or a series of comments to get the suspect to incriminate themselves. It doesn’t matter where the interrogation happens. It can occur in jail, at the scene of the crime, or the middle of a busy street. If the suspect is deprived of their freedom of action, such as being placed in handcuffs, they must be read their Miranda Rights. The determination of what is “custodial” comes down to whether a reasonable person would feel they are free to leave.

Many times, police do not arrest people when they talk to them. They let people know they are free to leave whenever they want during the conversation.  They start a conversation like this to avoid giving the Miranda Warning. However, if they get the suspect to self-incriminate, then will make an arrest.

Miranda Rights and DUI Arrests

Custodial interrogation is used to get information from a suspect. However, in the case of a DUI, questioning a drunk driver does not require the reading of Miranda Rights, even though the drive is not free to leave. DUI investigations are an exception to normal Miranda rules.

Gathering the police’s observations and a BAC test does not require a suspect to be Mirandized. However, if a DUI investigation turned to questions about something criminal and unrelated to the DUI, then the suspect would need Miranda Rights read to them.

Repercussions for Unlawful Custodial Interrogations

Many people think if there was a failure by law enforcement to read Miranda Warnings, the case will be dismissed. That is rarely correct. Rather the most common repercussion would be that anything said or obtained as a result of the custodial interrogation would be inadmissible, or it could not be used against the defendant in a trial. While this could lead to a dismissal, a dismissal is not an automatic certainty.

Jesse Kalter Law Always Reviews Cases for Proper Miranda Rights Procedures

An experienced criminal defense lawyer begins building their case by looking at evidence and the procedures that were used to collect the evidence. If those collection procedures weren’t followed exactly, the evidence could be deemed inadmissible, and the case could be dismissed. Jesse Kalter Law has the knowledge and experience to build a strong defense case. They have obtained countless not-guilty verdicts for DUI and domestic battery and have had other cases completely dismissed without a trial. They are available to serve the people of Reno, Sparks, Carson City, Fallon, Fernley, Dayton, Yerington, Douglas County, Hawthorne, and all other Northern NV rural counties.

Find Out If Your Case Needed Miranda Rights Read
Contact Jesse Kalter Law Today for a Confidential Case Evaluation and Consultation
CLICK HERE to Contact Online or Call 775-331-3888